QUOTE (blackdog @ Nov 11 2010, 12:34 PM)
Not really the same thing - protests, even when they turn violent, are a long way from bombings, shootings and knee capping. I guess that most governments have their roots in a violent struggle of some sort, certainly the English does.
Protest is a legitimate way of making clear one's feelings for or against something - sometimes it works. Without protests we wouldn't have the vote, we could be press ganged into the navy, we wouldn't have trade unions, hangings would be taking place all the time, we would be paying poll tax, etc. Many of the 'advances' (like them or loathe them) towards modern society, towards the things we now talk about as 'rights', were only won from the government of the day through protest.
You drew into question my example as being too extreme. I'd say that there is also a difference between the examples you gave in the second paragraph (examples ranging from social abuse through to tyranny) and the 'student riot'.