Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

Newbury Today Forum _ Random Rants _ New parking grace period and on-street parking

Posted by: Andy Capp Oct 22 2015, 09:14 PM

Does anyone know if this means that theoretically there is now ~40 minutes free parking?

Posted by: On the edge Oct 23 2015, 06:42 AM

I don't doubt it, the 'give them an inch' rule takes effect again. Let's face it, even if we had free parking round here, there would still be howls of protest because 'I was only parked on those double lines for a couple of minutes'.


Posted by: spartacus Oct 24 2015, 10:35 PM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Oct 22 2015, 10:14 PM) *
Does anyone know if this means that theoretically there is now ~40 minutes free parking?

I would say it does apply to Pay & Display bays. I can't do the link from this tablet but the website says "The 10 minute grace rules do not extend to vehicles parked in parking bays if a ticket hasn't been fixed on it first."

So, if you HAVE put your 30 minute 'free' ticket on your car (as you are meant to) they still have to give the 10 minute grace period in addition.


EDIT:

http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-3027454/Drivers-face-falling-foul-new-10-minute-grace-period-allowing-overstay-parking-bays-street-warns-parking-watchdog.html
(Second paragraph after the photo on the link:)
"The ten minute grace period kicks in only at the point when the time printed on the ticket expires."

Posted by: HeatherW Oct 26 2015, 05:02 PM

New parking is just driving people to other towns or the out limits of town.

Posted by: je suis Charlie Oct 26 2015, 05:22 PM

Agreed.

Posted by: On the edge Oct 26 2015, 05:42 PM

Even those of us who really don't mind paying to park are getting somewhat discontent at not seeing any sensible measures being taken to justify the monies taken. The Wharf area is a classic example. The whole area has the ambience of a derelict prison exercise yard. What an advert for the town this gateway had become; ugh!

Posted by: Spider Oct 26 2015, 08:26 PM

As a lorry driver it is becoming a lot harder for us drivers to find a parking space so we can deliver our goods. That is another reason why town centres will die.

Posted by: Cognosco Oct 26 2015, 09:26 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Oct 26 2015, 06:42 PM) *
Even those of us who really don't mind paying to park are getting somewhat discontent at not seeing any sensible measures being taken to justify the monies taken. The Wharf area is a classic example. The whole area has the ambience of a derelict prison exercise yard. What an advert for the town this gateway had become; ugh!


Terrific! Now you have given them another excuse to Give away yet some more land to a Developer! rolleyes.gif

Posted by: On the edge Oct 26 2015, 10:08 PM

QUOTE (Cognosco @ Oct 26 2015, 09:26 PM) *
Terrific! Now you have given them another excuse to Give away yet some more land to a Developer! rolleyes.gif



Aargh! Me and my big gob......no wonder Newbury people keep silent! laugh.gif

Posted by: je suis Charlie Oct 26 2015, 10:19 PM

QUOTE (Cognosco @ Oct 26 2015, 10:26 PM) *
Terrific! Now you have given them another excuse to Give away yet some more land to a Developer! rolleyes.gif

I thought the buses were going there?

Posted by: Exhausted Oct 26 2015, 10:26 PM

QUOTE (je suis Charlie @ Oct 26 2015, 10:19 PM) *
I thought the buses were going there?


Deja Vu.


Posted by: spartacus Oct 26 2015, 11:17 PM

QUOTE (Spider @ Oct 26 2015, 09:26 PM) *
As a lorry driver it is becoming a lot harder for us drivers to find a parking space so we can deliver our goods. That is another reason why town centres will die.

As a lorry driver you should know that you can 'deliver' on yellow lines, including double yellows. Opportunities exist for lorry drivers.

Of course lorry drivers can also be the scourge of town business parks with the swarms that invade for overnight parking. Instead of using the facilities that exist in the motorways, with toilets and even showers at some, lorry drivers prefer to avoid the parking fees and find a spot in the hidden away areas like Faraday Road and it's side roads. One reason why some businesses don't want to move into units in these areas when they become available is because they don't like having to deal with the turds on the doorstep or entrance areas smelling of pee. It's not a reason for them dying but it doesn't help regenerate an area when it's been used as a driver's toilet....

Posted by: je suis Charlie Oct 27 2015, 01:23 AM

QUOTE (Exhausted @ Oct 26 2015, 11:26 PM) *
Deja Vu.

Who's he then? rolleyes.gif

Posted by: On the edge Oct 27 2015, 06:49 AM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Oct 26 2015, 11:17 PM) *
As a lorry driver you should know that you can 'deliver' on yellow lines, including double yellows. Opportunities exist for lorry drivers.

Of course lorry drivers can also be the scourge of town business parks with the swarms that invade for overnight parking. Instead of using the facilities that exist in the motorways, with toilets and even showers at some, lorry drivers prefer to avoid the parking fees and find a spot in the hidden away areas like Faraday Road and it's side roads. One reason why some businesses don't want to move into units in these areas when they become available is because they don't like having to deal with the turds on the doorstep or entrance areas smelling of pee. It's not a reason for them dying but it doesn't help regenerate an area when it's been used as a driver's toilet....


Umm, this then says rather more about the quality of the business managers in the area than anything else. If the problem is as vile and endemic as suggested one might reasonably expected to have heard very loud noises about this beforehand - particularly in the mewling about the proposed development round there! Anyway, Spartacus, good to know we do have some civic problems that can't be laid at the door of WBC!

Posted by: Exhausted Oct 27 2015, 05:31 PM

QUOTE (je suis Charlie @ Oct 27 2015, 01:23 AM) *
Who's he then? rolleyes.gif


I swear it's Deja Vu
Know that I can't get over you
'Cause everything I see is you
And I don't want no substitute
Baby I swear it's Deja Vu.

Beyoncé.



Posted by: spartacus Oct 27 2015, 06:43 PM

QUOTE (Exhausted @ Oct 26 2015, 11:26 PM) *
Deja Vu.


Posted by: spartacus Oct 27 2015, 06:57 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Oct 27 2015, 07:49 AM) *
Umm, this then says rather more about the quality of the business managers in the area than anything else. If the problem is as vile and endemic as suggested one might reasonably expected to have heard very loud noises about this beforehand - particularly in the mewling about the proposed development round there!

I'm not sure how much control you might think a business manager could have over lorry drivers using Faraday Road area for overnight stops. It's public highway and there's nothing to stop them overnight.

Thankfully dealing with lorry driver 'solids' isn't a daily thing, but it does happen all too often, presumably once the Harvester closes and the toilets are off limits. With the large number of HGVs that park up there are also plenty who pee in doorways when it's raining and they have the urge in the middle of the night.

Posted by: On the edge Oct 27 2015, 09:20 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Oct 27 2015, 06:57 PM) *
I'm not sure how much control you might think a business manager could have over lorry drivers using Faraday Road area for overnight stops. It's public highway and there's nothing to stop them overnight.

Thankfully dealing with lorry driver 'solids' isn't a daily thing, but it does happen all too often, presumably once the Harvester closes and the toilets are off limits. With the large number of HGVs that park up there are also plenty who pee in doorways when it's raining and they have the urge in the middle of the night.


Just as much as the citizens of certain streets complaining about cars parking in front of their property; which has engaged Councillors and Officers. Measures such as yellow lining and even formal parking charges have been introduced. However, the Council can hardly act to solve a problem it doesn't know exists.

Similarly, with regard to fouling. If this is as common as suggested, why haven't we heard about it? There isn't much of a turnover in Lorry drivers so detection isn't going to be that difficult. 'All too often' suggests its regular enough to invest in a cheap video surveillance at least.

No, it's either an urban myth or evidence of slack property management.

Posted by: spartacus Oct 27 2015, 09:38 PM

WBC consulted businesses in this area several years ago to see if they wanted measures to ban HGVs from the area overnight and chase them back to the motorway services. The majority response from businesses was that on balance they preferred the 'security' of having truckers in place throughout the night rather than the place being deserted and a magnet for quiet crime or vandalism.

They complained about the toilet habits of some and still do. Finding a turd on your doorstep may only be a once every six months event, but that is 'all too often' in my book...

Posted by: Andy Capp Oct 27 2015, 09:53 PM

It could also be 'revellers' on their way home too.

Posted by: On the edge Oct 27 2015, 10:20 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Oct 27 2015, 09:38 PM) *
WBC consulted businesses in this area several years ago to see if they wanted measures to ban HGVs from the area overnight and chase them back to the motorway services. The majority response from businesses was that on balance they preferred the 'security' of having truckers in place throughout the night rather than the place being deserted and a magnet for quiet crime or vandalism.

They complained about the toilet habits of some and still do. Finding a turd on your doorstep may only be a once every six months event, but that is 'all too often' in my book...


I think my mate who has a town centre apartment is probably more deserving of sympathy. Not a Saturday night goes by without human waste from one end or the other being deposited by his gate. Perhaps the lorry drivers are simply copying the locals. After all when in Rome. That is, if the culprit is a lorry driver of course.

Posted by: Turin Machine Oct 27 2015, 11:12 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Oct 27 2015, 11:20 PM) *
I think my mate who has a town centre apartment is probably more deserving of sympathy. Not a Saturday night goes by without human waste from one end or the other being deposited by his gate. Perhaps the lorry drivers are simply copying the locals. After all when in Rome. That is, if the culprit is a lorry driver of course.

Ha! What have the Romans ever done for us?

Posted by: x2lls Oct 27 2015, 11:32 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Oct 27 2015, 11:20 PM) *
I think my mate who has a town centre apartment is probably more deserving of sympathy. Not a Saturday night goes by without human waste from one end or the other being deposited by his gate. Perhaps the lorry drivers are simply copying the locals. After all when in Rome. That is, if the culprit is a lorry driver of course.



OK, so now we go down the road of Top Gear and blame all the lorryists of pooing in the street.

If your 'mate'. (Not the fat bloke down the pub), had any sense and understanding of electricity, he could nail the culprits.


Posted by: spartacus Oct 27 2015, 11:38 PM

I think OTE is referring to town party-goers and the pavement pizzas liberally thrown (up) around town after a busy weekend of 'revelling'. I'm on about truckers with loose bowels.

Posted by: x2lls Oct 28 2015, 12:14 AM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Oct 28 2015, 12:38 AM) *
I think OTE is referring to town party-goers and the pavement pizzas liberally thrown (up) around town after a busy weekend of 'revelling'. I'm on about truckers with loose bowels.



An a$$hole is an a$$hole..


Posted by: On the edge Oct 28 2015, 07:29 AM

I like the idea x2lls - an electric door mat would probably be more effective than a camera!

Nonetheless, I think Spartacus has explained, I for one am far from convinced that lorry drivers are causing the problem.

Posted by: blackdog Oct 28 2015, 10:35 AM

Not a lot of point in doing much about lorries in Faraday Road - they are already planning to flatten the lot in the next year or two.

As for the wharf - the plans were not so much to flatten as to dig down, turn it into a couple of ponds. Needless to say this involved giving away land - notably the Waterside Centre and a chunk by the Park Way bridge (for a nice new pub).

What sort of thing are you hoping for OTE, a nice new multi-story car park? Or a big underground one (time to get the pumps going again)?


Posted by: On the edge Oct 28 2015, 01:11 PM

QUOTE (blackdog @ Oct 28 2015, 10:35 AM) *
Not a lot of point in doing much about lorries in Faraday Road - they are already planning to flatten the lot in the next year or two.

As for the wharf - the plans were not so much to flatten as to dig down, turn it into a couple of ponds. Needless to say this involved giving away land - notably the Waterside Centre and a chunk by the Park Way bridge (for a nice new pub).

What sort of thing are you hoping for OTE, a nice new multi-story car park? Or a big underground one (time to get the pumps going again)?


Just a bit of intelligence in the overall layout. It would look far better as a sheet of level Tarmac, but without the derelict fencing, concrete posts and redundant pavements. Stop pretending there is a road through the site and just lay it out as a car park. Make the gate to the bridge a real one; only buses should use that. There is absolutely no reason why the Market exit shouldn't be closed completely, but the taxi mafia would doubtless scupper that - but even so a simple gate would suffice.

Posted by: Simon Kirby Oct 28 2015, 09:43 PM

QUOTE (blackdog @ Oct 28 2015, 10:35 AM) *
Not a lot of point in doing much about lorries in Faraday Road - they are already planning to flatten the lot in the next year or two.

As for the wharf - the plans were not so much to flatten as to dig down, turn it into a couple of ponds. Needless to say this involved giving away land - notably the Waterside Centre and a chunk by the Park Way bridge (for a nice new pub).

What sort of thing are you hoping for OTE, a nice new multi-story car park? Or a big underground one (time to get the pumps going again)?

Can you say any more about what is planned for Faraday Road and the Wharf? Does the development of Faraday Road extend all the wy down Ampere Road? Is the Wharf basin going to be dug out?

Posted by: blackdog Oct 28 2015, 11:28 PM

QUOTE (Simon Kirby @ Oct 28 2015, 09:43 PM) *
Can you say any more about what is planned for Faraday Road and the Wharf? Does the development of Faraday Road extend all the wy down Ampere Road? Is the Wharf basin going to be dug out?

I have no special knowledge, the extent of the Faraday Road revamp seems to change with each map printed by the NWN - the original scheme was fairly limited but WBC seem to have widened it loads. I have no idea how far down Ampere Road it goes, though the council do own a fair chunk of the land down there so some of it will be included.

The scope seems to be most of the estate - http://www.newburytoday.co.uk/news/news/12789/New-A339-access-to-Faraday-Road.html

The big dig in the Wharf has gone quiet since the public outcry scuppered the pavilion in the park - but I suspect a Wharf revamp is still lurking somewhere in the Vision.

Posted by: greenmeanie61 Nov 6 2015, 09:22 AM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Oct 22 2015, 10:14 PM) *
Does anyone know if this means that theoretically there is now ~40 minutes free parking?


The 10 minute grace period is for vehicles displaying expired pay and display tickets.
If you don't have a pay and display ticket then a 5 minute observation period applies before a PCN is issued.

Having spoken to my colleagues to see what their feedback is from members of the public, the new charges have had a largly positive response from drivers. There are now almost always space to park in Cheap Street and Bartholomew Street and a lot of people are grateful of this.

I personally believe it is the shops responsibilty to tempt shoppers into the town, not the council's.

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 6 2015, 09:56 AM

QUOTE (greenmeanie61 @ Nov 6 2015, 09:22 AM) *
The 10 minute grace period is for vehicles displaying expired pay and display tickets.

Thanks, but is a '30 minute' ticket considered a 'pay and display' ticket?

Posted by: spartacus Nov 6 2015, 10:28 AM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Nov 6 2015, 09:56 AM) *
Thanks, but is a '30 minute' ticket considered a 'pay and display' ticket?

Yes it is a 'Pay & Display' ticket, it's just that the tariff for the 30 minute period is zero. Tariff for 1 hour is £1.

Press the button twice for a ticket allowing you to stay for 30 minutes. Display that. The enforcement officers have to observe the vehicle for 10 minutes before they can slap a ticket on.

What I'm not sure (and GM can perhaps clarify) is your question assumes the officer is walking past a car smack on the 30 minute period and therefore a further 10 minutes of observation before prosecution allows 40 minutes parking. These officers in green can't be everywhere all the time though, so if they happen to check a car on one of their patrols and the driver has chanced it and the car has been there for an hour with just the 'free ticket' displayed without paying, does the CEO still have to give a further 10 minutes grace period before they can stick a ticket on or can they print off an instant enforcement ticket?

Posted by: Simon Kirby Nov 6 2015, 01:08 PM

QUOTE ("Caroline Sheppard @ chief Adjudicator at the Traffic Penalty Tribunal")
The new grace period applies in limited circumstances and not to parking on yellow lines. It does not allow a driver to park for an extra ten minutes, it just means the council will not issue a Penalty Charge Notice until ten minutes have passed since the parking time paid for has elapsed.

from: http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-3027454/Drivers-face-falling-foul-new-10-minute-grace-period-allowing-overstay-parking-bays-street-warns-parking-watchdog.html#ixzz3qiTTkZUU

So you don't appear to get 10 minutes of observation time, just 10 minutes of grace past the ticket expiry time.

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 6 2015, 01:39 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 6 2015, 10:28 AM) *
Yes it is a 'Pay & Display' ticket, it's just that the tariff for the 30 minute period is zero. Tariff for 1 hour is £1.

I think the term Pay and Display is now out of date and misleading. It should now just be called a parking ticket. I think big signs should say quite clearly: No parking without displaying a ticket.

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 6 2015, 10:28 AM) *
Press the button twice for a ticket allowing you to stay for 30 minutes. Display that. The enforcement officers have to observe the vehicle for 10 minutes before they can slap a ticket on.

That can't be right, can it?

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 6 2015, 10:28 AM) *
What I'm not sure (and GM can perhaps clarify) is your question assumes the officer is walking past a car smack on the 30 minute period and therefore a further 10 minutes of observation before prosecution allows 40 minutes parking. These officers in green can't be everywhere all the time though, so if they happen to check a car on one of their patrols and the driver has chanced it and the car has been there for an hour with just the 'free ticket' displayed without paying, does the CEO still have to give a further 10 minutes grace period before they can stick a ticket on or can they print off an instant enforcement ticket?

I read it that greenmeanie61 said that a parking tax collection officer will give someone 5 minutes to put a ticket on the vehicle (or sod off), which is a separate issue.

Posted by: spartacus Nov 6 2015, 01:48 PM

I assume it's national, but here in Reading if you're parked on yellow lines they have to give you 5 minutes of observation time, to make sure you aren't in the process of loading/unloading. The software on their handheld machines does not allow a ticket to be printed out instantly for that violation code. (If you're parked where there is a loading ban or where there is a 'No Stopping' restriction that's a different violation code and the 5 minute period does not apply and a ticket can be printed instantly)

If you're parked in a Limited Waiting or Pay & Display bay they now have to give you 10 minutes of observation beyond the expired time before they can issue a ticket and that is also presumably programmed into their handheld devices. From the comment Simon has put up it seems clear that you could park for 40 minutes in the 30 minute/1 hour bay without paying.

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 6 2015, 01:53 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 6 2015, 01:48 PM) *
If you're parked in a Limited Waiting or Pay & Display bay they now have to give you 10 minutes of observation beyond the expired time before they can issue a ticket and that is also presumably programmed into their handheld devices. From the comment Simon has put up it seems clear that you could park for 40 minutes in the 30 minute/1 hour bay without paying.

If you have a ticket that is 30 minutes over time, I'd 'like' to think there is a code which allows for an instant print.

Posted by: spartacus Nov 6 2015, 01:54 PM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Nov 6 2015, 01:39 PM) *
I think the term Pay and Display is now out of date and misleading. It should now just be called a parking ticket. I think big signs should say quite clearly: No parking without displaying a ticket.

That wouldn't take into account the modern method of 'PaybyPhone'. No ticket displayed.

The 'Pay & Display' term is just an expression we're used to which may no longer be strictly accurate but we know what we mean. It's like people of my age saying they're going to tape their favourite programme off the telly when there's no 'tape' involved any more.... wink.gif

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 6 2015, 02:00 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 6 2015, 01:54 PM) *
That wouldn't take into account the modern method of 'PaybyPhone'. No ticket displayed.

I assumed a 'PaybyPhone' need still to print a ticket?

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 6 2015, 01:54 PM) *
The 'Pay & Display' term is just an expression we're used to which may no longer be strictly accurate but we know what we mean. It's like people of my age saying they're going to tape their favourite programme off the telly when there's no 'tape' involved any more.... wink.gif

I understand that, but pay and display is multi faceted 'noun' and I think it is misleading.

Posted by: Rdg Nov 6 2015, 02:55 PM

Several pay by phone systems you txt them your reg number, they then have it in the system which uses ANPR to watch the car park entrance - if your number is in system no problem, if not sends a fine after looking up reg number on dvla database.

No warden to pay

Posted by: greenmeanie61 Nov 6 2015, 03:08 PM

A pay and display ticket is the thing that comes out of the pay and display machine. As Spartacus rightly says, everyone knows what that is. A parking ticket is what people think you receive on your windscreen when receiving a fine on or off private land. I believe a renaming would cause confusion. i.e. If you don't get a parking ticket, you'll get a parking ticket etc etc etc. Also, for the sake of accuracy, we are not "Parking Tax collection officers". We do not collect any money ourselves, we issue a PCN when we believe a contravention has occured on the public highway, in the interests of road safety and fairness for all. It is for the council parking services to decide whether the contravention stands and whether a penalty is payable.

So, if we come a cross a vehicle without clearly displaying a pay and display ticket, we would check to see if the vehicle is covered by mobile phone payment. If it isn't then we observe the vehicle for 5 minutes to make sure the driver hasn't gone off to get change. After the 5 minutes is up, we check the pay by phone system one last time and if the driver still hasn't paid, then a PCN can be issued. To clarify, 5 minutes observation is all that is required for no display in the West Berkshire Council area. *(It could very well be different for other local authorities.)

Expired pay and display tickets have a 10 minute grace period; so if we come across a vehicle with a pay and display ticket which has expired, we allow 10 minutes over the printed time. Example. If we saw a car at 12:30 with a ticket that expired at 12:00 we would issue a PCN straight away as the 10 minute grace period has already been observed. If we saw a vehicle at 14:30 with a ticket that expired at 14:32, we wouldn't be able to issue a PCN until 14:42 at the earliest. I think that this is a national standard for on street parking and council controlled pay and display car parks. Private car parks can do what they like.

You obviously won't have anything to display when you park and pay via the mobile phone payment system. This is explained in WBC parking policy, and also the pay by phone terms and conditions, which you agree to before paying and commencing your parking period. Our hand-held computers link into the system so we can see who has paid.

So you may park in Cheap Street and Bartholomew (in theory) for 40 minutes without paying, but not without displaying. I say in theory because the maximum free period is officially 30 minutes, with a grace period. Be fair to everyone else, we have to share our public highway!

Posted by: greenmeanie61 Nov 6 2015, 03:15 PM

QUOTE (Rdg @ Nov 6 2015, 02:55 PM) *
Several pay by phone systems you txt them your reg number, they then have it in the system which uses ANPR to watch the car park entrance - if your number is in system no problem, if not sends a fine after looking up reg number on dvla database.

No warden to pay


I'd rather have a friendly green meanie to talk to than big brother watching my every move.

The private ANPR enforcement of car parks is hardly perfect, and causes misery for hundreds of people everyday. Not a clever solution.

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 6 2015, 07:15 PM

QUOTE (greenmeanie61 @ Nov 6 2015, 03:08 PM) *
A pay and display ticket is the thing that comes out of the pay and display machine. As Spartacus rightly says, everyone knows what that is.

It is not whether people know what a 'pay and display ticket' is, but whether they know they need one when parking on the road for 30 minutes or less. I know for a fact there are people who don't know they are meant to get tickets when parking for a short period.

QUOTE (greenmeanie61 @ Nov 6 2015, 03:08 PM) *
Also, for the sake of accuracy, we are not "Parking Tax collection officers". We do not collect any money ourselves, we issue a PCN when we believe a contravention has occured on the public highway, in the interests of road safety and fairness for all. It is for the council parking services to decide whether the contravention stands and whether a penalty is payable.

The reason for my flippant reference was simply that I believe the principle reason parking charges and fines were introduced (as is also the case with some instances of speeding) was to raise revenue.

Posted by: Simon Kirby Nov 6 2015, 08:10 PM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Nov 6 2015, 07:15 PM) *
It is not whether people know what a 'pay and display ticket' is, but whether they know they need one when parking on the road for 30 minutes or less. I know for a fact there are people who don't know they are meant to get tickets when parking for a short period.


The reason for my flippant reference was simply that I believe the principle reason parking charges and fines were introduced (as is also the case with some instances of speeding) was to raise revenue.

The proposal to increase parking charges as part of the WBC response to their losing £11M ofcentral government funding does indeed suggest that parking chargesare seen as an income stream

Posted by: On the edge Nov 6 2015, 08:59 PM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Nov 6 2015, 07:15 PM) *
It is not whether people know what a 'pay and display ticket' is, but whether they know they need one when parking on the road for 30 minutes or less. I know for a fact there are people who don't know they are meant to get tickets when parking for a short period.


Actually, Andy Capp, I was one of them! On the basis of that's how it works elsewhere I've been.

I do know about the not needing a ticket with the phone pay ones though. Got caught at Newbury Station which cost me! Entirely my fault, ran for train, about to 'log in and pay' and the phone went, took the call and forgot.....'till I got back. Bang to rights they call it!

Posted by: HJD Nov 23 2015, 04:37 PM

QUOTE (HeatherW @ Oct 26 2015, 05:02 PM) *
New parking is just driving people to other towns or the out limits of town.


Well it looks like Basingstoke has the right idea. I quote from the 'Basingstoke & Deane Today Paper'
:- 'To help support a thriving town centre, the half hour free parking in short stay council run car parks in Basingstoke is planned to increase to an hour. The move follows feedback that the half hour parking the council introduced was to much of a rush for people wanting to just nip into town to sort something out or make a quick purchase'.
Now, doesn't that make sense !!

Posted by: je suis Charlie Nov 23 2015, 05:11 PM

It sounds to me, like a council initiative from someone who actually gives a **** about their town. Well done Basingstoke!

Posted by: The Hatter Nov 23 2015, 06:41 PM

It's quite a walk from their car parks. The extra half hour is needed just to get to the shops and back.

Posted by: spartacus Nov 23 2015, 08:14 PM

QUOTE (HJD @ Nov 23 2015, 04:37 PM) *
Well it looks like Basingstoke has the right idea. I quote from the 'Basingstoke & Deane Today Paper'
:- 'To help support a thriving town centre, the half hour free parking in short stay council run car parks in Basingstoke is planned to increase to an hour. The move follows feedback that the half hour parking the council introduced was to much of a rush for people wanting to just nip into town to sort something out or make a quick purchase'.
Now, doesn't that make sense !!

Yes let's compare Basingstoke with Newbury..... As Hatter says, the free half hour is pretty much used up just to get to the shops and back. What sort of "just nipping into town to sort something out or make a quick purchase" requires a whole hour in Newbury?

Posted by: On the edge Nov 23 2015, 08:34 PM

I have to say, I rarely pay to park in Newbury these days if I want to be quick. Since the free half hour, it's been reasonably easy to find somewhere close to the centre. Mind, I don't actually resent paying a pound for an hour in Parkway just so my better half can fill the boot without walking too far. Dare I say it's rather nice being able to wander around a good few shops in the car free centre whilst breathing real air and without the canned music.

Posted by: newres Nov 23 2015, 09:24 PM

The thing I don't like is that the necessity to take a ticket for half an hour's free parking is just a cynical and sly means of taxing the unwary. Just plain nasty.


Posted by: On the edge Nov 23 2015, 09:31 PM

QUOTE (newres @ Nov 23 2015, 09:24 PM) *
The thing I don't like is that the necessity to take a ticket for half an hour's free parking is just a cynical and sly means of taxing the unwary. Just plain nasty.


I'm not entirely convinced about that. Arguably, the only contention about having to take a ticket is the apparent lack of a plain clear notice explaining?

Posted by: spartacus Nov 23 2015, 09:42 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Nov 23 2015, 09:31 PM) *
Arguably, the only contention about having to take a ticket is the apparent lack of a plain clear notice explaining?

Don't the yellow signs say something like "Display ticket for free 30 minutes parking"? Perhaps it could be better worded but I'm not sure whether the sign then starts to become too 'wordy'.

Posted by: newres Nov 23 2015, 09:42 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Nov 23 2015, 09:31 PM) *
I'm not entirely convinced about that. Arguably, the only contention about having to take a ticket is the apparent lack of a plain clear notice explaining?

Sorry, my post failed to state that not clearly informing of the need to take a ticket is the cynical bit.
I can't think of any reason not to have a plain clear notice explaining other than in the hope of catching the unwary?

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 23 2015, 09:46 PM

QUOTE (newres @ Nov 23 2015, 09:24 PM) *
The thing I don't like is that the necessity to take a ticket for half an hour's free parking is just a cynical and sly means of taxing the unwary. Just plain nasty.

It is a odd, but it is probably more likely to be there to make 'policing' the parking time easier for the 'meanies', otherwise they have to be there and time you, and the others.

Posted by: On the edge Nov 23 2015, 09:48 PM

QUOTE (newres @ Nov 23 2015, 09:42 PM) *
Sorry, my post failed to state that not clearly informing of the need to take a ticket is the cynical bit.
I can't think of any reason not to have a plain clear notice explaining other than in the hope of catching the unwary?


Yes, I'd go with that, I was 'caught' a couple of times before I realised!

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 23 2015, 09:50 PM

It is most likely to make traffic management easier (a record of when you took a ticket). I doubt it is entrapment.

Posted by: spartacus Nov 23 2015, 10:52 PM

QUOTE (newres @ Nov 23 2015, 09:24 PM) *
The thing I don't like is that the necessity to take a ticket for half an hour's free parking is just a cynical and sly means of taxing the unwary. Just plain nasty.

Without a means to show what time you turned up and started your 30 minute free parking period how can the Enforcement Officers reasonably hope to enforce? They can't be expected to be there and patrol continually on a single street to record every single car that turns up and parks on that street.

Posted by: On the edge Nov 24 2015, 07:27 AM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 23 2015, 10:52 PM) *
Without a means to show what time you turned up and started your 30 minute free parking period how can the Enforcement Officers reasonably hope to enforce? They can't be expected to be there and patrol continually on a single street to record every single car that turns up and parks on that street.


Mind, they always used to; before the march of technology, but we had to employ rather more back then. I'd agree it isn't exactly entrapment, if the signage is indistinct or unclear, it could just be poor implementation which might be caused by a lack of customer focus. Its a shame really, it could have been a highlight,

Posted by: greenmeanie61 Nov 24 2015, 10:51 AM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 23 2015, 10:52 PM) *
Without a means to show what time you turned up and started your 30 minute free parking period how can the Enforcement Officers reasonably hope to enforce? They can't be expected to be there and patrol continually on a single street to record every single car that turns up and parks on that street.


In fact that is exactly what we used to do before the pay and display machines, but rather than standing in one road all the time, we would patrol each road every 15/20 minutes and take a snapshot of cars parked. Our patrol areas cover lots of roads and timed bays so we can't be everywhere at the same time. A better way? You decide.

Posted by: greenmeanie61 Nov 24 2015, 11:02 AM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Nov 24 2015, 07:27 AM) *
Mind, they always used to; before the march of technology, but we had to employ rather more back then. I'd agree it isn't exactly entrapment, if the signage is indistinct or unclear, it could just be poor implementation which might be caused by a lack of customer focus. Its a shame really, it could have been a highlight,


Perhaps a problem with public highway parking regulation signs in general is that the designs are prescribed by Whitehall bureaucrats at the DfT, with mixed results. If the council had more leeway with the design, implementation may have been different. It's a toss up between regulating the road space effectively, adequate signage informing of sometimes complex restrictions and not causing sign clutter which can lead to confusion.

Posted by: On the edge Nov 24 2015, 11:28 AM

QUOTE (greenmeanie61 @ Nov 24 2015, 11:02 AM) *
Perhaps a problem with public highway parking regulation signs in general is that the designs are prescribed by Whitehall bureaucrats at the DfT, with mixed results. If the council had more leeway with the design, implementation may have been different. It's a toss up between regulating the road space effectively, adequate signage informing of sometimes complex restrictions and not causing sign clutter which can lead to confusion.


Again, I've some sympathy with this. Particularly following the Parkway Bridge fiasco, where there were a huge amount of complaints about what seemed to be perfectly adequate signage. Perhaps it's time we started to go back hard to DfT and make them rather more accountable; presumably our local Councillors have access to Richard B?

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 24 2015, 12:30 PM

The problems start when you have conditional use. The less ambiguous the situation the better, but we are trying to fit a 21st century solution into a 19th century environment.

Posted by: scott Nov 24 2015, 04:24 PM

My biggest issue with the whole display a ticket for 30 minutes free parking was the delivery.

When the parking charges came in to play, the council made a big noise about in the press and twitter etc, then some time after this the rules changed. It was initially 30 minute free. end of story, then as you can tell from the signs now being changed (which at 8ft up are not that obvious!) they changed their minds as they obviously couldnt work out how to 'police' it.

I feel the way this change was implemented without any announcement in the press, no changes to the parking terms and conditions on the WBC website is under hand or at the very best, poorly implemented.

And yes, i am waiting for the reply to my appeal as i parked up on Bart street to run to Lloyds bank, was there for no more than 15 minutes and returned to a penalty notice completely unaware i 'should' have displayed a free ticket. I was livid when i returned to the car and a kind local shop keeper explained what changes had happened.

Lets see what happens, still feel hard done by with the way the changes were implemented...

Posted by: newres Nov 24 2015, 04:35 PM

QUOTE (scott @ Nov 24 2015, 04:24 PM) *
My biggest issue with the whole display a ticket for 30 minutes free parking was the delivery.

When the parking charges came in to play, the council made a big noise about in the press and twitter etc, then some time after this the rules changed. It was initially 30 minute free. end of story, then as you can tell from the signs now being changed (which at 8ft up are not that obvious!) they changed their minds as they obviously couldnt work out how to 'police' it.

I feel the way this change was implemented without any announcement in the press, no changes to the parking terms and conditions on the WBC website is under hand or at the very best, poorly implemented.

And yes, i am waiting for the reply to my appeal as i parked up on Bart street to run to Lloyds bank, was there for no more than 15 minutes and returned to a penalty notice completely unaware i 'should' have displayed a free ticket. I was livid when i returned to the car and a kind local shop keeper explained what changes had happened.

Lets see what happens, still feel hard done by with the way the changes were implemented...

It's worth appealing to the tribunal when WBC turn you down. I did on another matter and one I was seemingly destined to lose but I won on a technicality that the adjudicator spotted.

Posted by: On the edge Nov 24 2015, 04:38 PM

QUOTE (scott @ Nov 24 2015, 04:24 PM) *
My biggest issue with the whole display a ticket for 30 minutes free parking was the delivery.

When the parking charges came in to play, the council made a big noise about in the press and twitter etc, then some time after this the rules changed. It was initially 30 minute free. end of story, then as you can tell from the signs now being changed (which at 8ft up are not that obvious!) they changed their minds as they obviously couldnt work out how to 'police' it.

I feel the way this change was implemented without any announcement in the press, no changes to the parking terms and conditions on the WBC website is under hand or at the very best, poorly implemented.

And yes, i am waiting for the reply to my appeal as i parked up on Bart street to run to Lloyds bank, was there for no more than 15 minutes and returned to a penalty notice completely unaware i 'should' have displayed a free ticket. I was livid when i returned to the car and a kind local shop keeper explained what changes had happened.

Lets see what happens, still feel hard done by with the way the changes were implemented...


That's a brilliant outline and perfectly illustrates our beloved local Council's biggest problem. Their greatest strength seems to be the ability to turn lemonade back into lemons in a trice. A 'good news' story smashed by half cocked implementation! The issue with DfT notwithstanding, don't they actually employ any real project managers or publicity officers? There is sometimes a feeling abroad that all we do is criticise our Local Council; herein lies the reason.

Posted by: newres Nov 24 2015, 04:56 PM

QUOTE (scott @ Nov 24 2015, 04:24 PM) *
My biggest issue with the whole display a ticket for 30 minutes free parking was the delivery.

When the parking charges came in to play, the council made a big noise about in the press and twitter etc, then some time after this the rules changed. It was initially 30 minute free. end of story, then as you can tell from the signs now being changed (which at 8ft up are not that obvious!) they changed their minds as they obviously couldnt work out how to 'police' it.

I feel the way this change was implemented without any announcement in the press, no changes to the parking terms and conditions on the WBC website is under hand or at the very best, poorly implemented.

And yes, i am waiting for the reply to my appeal as i parked up on Bart street to run to Lloyds bank, was there for no more than 15 minutes and returned to a penalty notice completely unaware i 'should' have displayed a free ticket. I was livid when i returned to the car and a kind local shop keeper explained what changes had happened.

Lets see what happens, still feel hard done by with the way the changes were implemented...

Although if you've ever parked at Northcroft, the same system operates when the ticket machines are working. I think the thing is that it's unexpected on the whole, hence it catches so many out.

Posted by: scott Nov 24 2015, 05:09 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Nov 24 2015, 04:38 PM) *
That's a brilliant outline and perfectly illustrates our beloved local Council's biggest problem. Their greatest strength seems to be the ability to turn lemonade back into lemons in a trice. A 'good news' story smashed by half cocked implementation! The issue with DfT notwithstanding, don't they actually employ any real project managers or publicity officers? There is sometimes a feeling abroad that all we do is criticise our Local Council; herein lies the reason.


Thank you, I dread my parents or even my grandparents parking in the town! They wouldn't have a clue! I like to think i keep a 'finger on the pulse' and know whats happening, where i can park, where not etc. It must be an absolute minefield for 'out of towners' and those less aware shall we say.

It is frustrating when there is half cocked implementation. For example, Deadmans Lane and leading into sandleford lane, montague drive etc, and another site around the schools at John Rankin Jr and Infant. (this one is two fold!!)

Anyway, both locations over the past 12 months had parking restriction markings implemented. Both sites the rules are constantly ignored and the drivers that regularly ignore the rules know they can get away with it as there are never any patrols.

I said the John Rankin one was two fold, I did have to laugh as they painted the lines, then 3 months later resurfaced the entire road meaning the lines had to be painted again. Hey ho, it keeps guys in a job i suppose!!

While i am still on a rant.... The motor park, how come all off the staff are now flooding into the estates off deadmans lane? too much sales stock, not enough parking for staff so they park their cars in residential roads. I feel a letter and tweets to the car manufacturers! In fact, Honda were very good last time i abused them due to their transporter unloading cars 15m from the roundabout at 8:15AM one morning causing gridlock!

Sorry folks, i do feel better though for getting all that out!!

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 24 2015, 06:22 PM

QUOTE (scott @ Nov 24 2015, 05:09 PM) *
Thank you, I dread my parents or even my grandparents parking in the town! They wouldn't have a clue! I like to think i keep a 'finger on the pulse' and know whats happening, where i can park, where not etc. It must be an absolute minefield for 'out of towners' and those less aware shall we say.

Yes. I have a similar thought about mine who have lived in or around the town nearly all their lives.

Posted by: spartacus Nov 24 2015, 07:20 PM

QUOTE (scott @ Nov 24 2015, 05:09 PM) *
I said the John Rankin one was two fold, I did have to laugh as they painted the lines, then 3 months later resurfaced the entire road meaning the lines had to be painted again. Hey ho, it keeps guys in a job i suppose!!

Yellow lines are often put in for a safety reason near a school. Would you prefer they waited 3 or 4 months until the resurfacing contractors turned up? Yellow paint is pretty cheap in the scheme of things.

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 24 2015, 07:56 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 24 2015, 07:20 PM) *
Yellow lines are often put in for a safety reason near a school. Would you prefer they waited 3 or 4 months until the resurfacing contractors turned up? Yellow paint is pretty cheap in the scheme of things.

I wonder how long the painting had gone before the first re-coat! tongue.gif

Posted by: spartacus Nov 24 2015, 09:36 PM

QUOTE (scott @ Nov 24 2015, 04:24 PM) *
My biggest issue with the whole display a ticket for 30 minutes free parking was the delivery.

When the parking charges came in to play, the council made a big noise about in the press and twitter etc, then some time after this the rules changed. It was initially 30 minute free. end of story, then as you can tell from the signs now being changed (which at 8ft up are not that obvious!) they changed their minds as they obviously couldnt work out how to 'police' it.

The yellow signs initially said this: (from the http://www.newburytoday.co.uk/news/news/15826/Fury-over-more-on-street-parking.html)



These were similar to the other signs put up around town around two years ago (?) for the other sites at Old Bath Road and Faraday Road which GMR got so hot under the collar about.

Rather than remove them I think they probably changed the yellow signs to take into account people like yourself who were getting caught out because they weren't reading the tariff boards on the ticket machines properly (or weren't bothering to read them at all if you're honest wink.gif )

Posted by: On the edge Nov 24 2015, 09:55 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 24 2015, 09:36 PM) *
The yellow signs initially said this: (from the http://www.newburytoday.co.uk/news/news/15826/Fury-over-more-on-street-parking.html)



These were similar to the other signs put up around town around two years ago (?) for the other sites at Old Bath Road and Faraday Road which GMR got so hot under the collar about.

Rather than remove them I think they probably changed the yellow signs to take into account people like yourself who were getting caught out because they weren't reading the tariff boards on the ticket machines properly (or weren't bothering to read them at all if you're honest wink.gif )


Yes, you are spot on. I was one who didn't bother to read what was written on the machines, indeed, I didn't even look. Simply, I'd read that it was half an hour free, so I took it to be usual custom and practice for that first half hour; in fact, as it is in a couple of other towns I drive around. How would the Warden know? Well, in exactly the same way as he would if I'd parked in a time restricted zone where there were no meters; not exactly rocket science. Anyway, I wasn't caught and have now caught up with the rules. Yes, it was all my fault, I should have read the new small print, sorry, I'm just a simple customer...

Posted by: spartacus Nov 24 2015, 10:49 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Nov 24 2015, 09:55 PM) *
I'd read that it was half an hour free, so I took it to be usual custom and practice for that first half hour; in fact, as it is in a couple of other towns I drive around.

But WHERE had you read that it was 30 minutes free?

In the paper?
Before it was added to the yellow signs it would have been on the little notices in the ticket machines. And if you'd read that bit you would have seen the other bit that told you to press the button twice for a free ticket.
There's no mention of free 30 minutes parking on the white signs above (or below) the yellow signs (forget the signs in that photo as it's from an old NWN article) so presumably you did at least go to the machine but just scanned rather than 'read'?

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 24 2015, 11:15 PM

What I think it should say is: No parking without displaying a ticket*

Then on the tariff display it can say: *No ticket required when paying by phone.

Posted by: On the edge Nov 25 2015, 07:43 AM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 24 2015, 10:49 PM) *
But WHERE had you read that it was 30 minutes free?

In the paper?
Before it was added to the yellow signs it would have been on the little notices in the ticket machines. And if you'd read that bit you would have seen the other bit that told you to press the button twice for a free ticket.
There's no mention of free 30 minutes parking on the white signs above (or below) the yellow signs (forget the signs in that photo as it's from an old NWN article) so presumably you did at least go to the machine but just scanned rather than 'read'?


I'm sure it did, chapter and verse and I'm sure the signage erected conformed to the various road traffic acts and the regulations and the statutory instruments and I'm sure that if I'd been given a ticket the Warden would have had me bang to rights and yes, absolutely, the demeanour was all my fault, honestly and seriously.

Then there is the response by Andy Capp. 'What I think it should say is: No parking without displaying a ticket*Then on the tariff display it can say: *No ticket required when paying by phone.' I don't think he has a degree in Customer Service or works for a local authority.

Can you see the difference?

Posted by: spartacus Nov 25 2015, 06:34 PM

QUOTE (On the edge @ Nov 25 2015, 07:43 AM) *
I'm sure it did, chapter and verse and I'm sure the signage erected conformed to the various road traffic acts and the regulations and the statutory instruments and I'm sure that if I'd been given a ticket the Warden would have had me bang to rights and yes, absolutely, the demeanour was all my fault, honestly and seriously.

Then there is the response by Andy Capp. 'What I think it should say is: No parking without displaying a ticket*Then on the tariff display it can say: *No ticket required when paying by phone.' I don't think he has a degree in Customer Service or works for a local authority.

Can you see the difference?

ooooh.... get her!

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 25 2015, 06:44 PM

I wonder what would happen if one collected a free ticket, then after realising they will be some time, came back and paid by phone without removing the ticket from the dashboard? Would a meanie check for a phone payment? What about people just renewing their free ticket several times? Presumably the meanie would have to have recorded the vehicle's presence to know that?

Posted by: je suis Charlie Nov 25 2015, 06:50 PM

QUOTE (spartacus @ Nov 25 2015, 06:34 PM) *
ooooh.... get her!

Cyber bullying.

Posted by: On the edge Nov 25 2015, 06:59 PM

QUOTE (je suis Charlie @ Nov 25 2015, 06:50 PM) *
Cyber bullying.


Nah, simply can't defend the undefendable! laugh.gif

Posted by: spartacus Nov 25 2015, 08:45 PM

QUOTE (Andy Capp @ Nov 25 2015, 06:44 PM) *
What about people just renewing their free ticket several times? Presumably the meanie would have to have recorded the vehicle's presence to know that?

Why not try it out and let the forum know how you get on?

wink.gif

Posted by: Andy Capp Nov 25 2015, 09:04 PM

So it means then perhaps the meanies do have the wherewithal to record the parking time! ohmy.gif So it is a conspiracy!!! ohmy.gif ohmy.gif

Give it a few years and I'll come back as a foot shuffling zombie and eat them!

Posted by: On the edge Nov 25 2015, 09:19 PM

It seems to work without tickets in other towns and some have been doing it for a good time before us. So, if it's not a conspiracy, or slipshod implementation, perhaps there is another reason? The vending machine salesman had probably demonstrated the new 'free vend' feature which comes with the super deluxe model at just a few quid extra?

Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)